The Trigger Pull Weight Debate
Trigger Pull: Light is Right
By: Arthur J. Viani
I am the owner of Ghost Inc. I invented, manufacture
and sell the Ghost Rocket, Ghost Tactical, Ghost Trigger, Ghost Ranger, Ghost
Patrol and Ghost Ultimate. These trigger connectors improve the Glock OEM triggers by
eliminating trigger over-travel and debris from
the trigger mechanism. The benefit of a Ghost trigger is
significantly enhanced trigger efficiency and reliability.
If your intention is to hit where you are aiming your
Glock, and if accuracy and speed are an issue, a smooth lighter Ghost
trigger in the 3.5 to 5.5 lb. range with little or no trigger
over-travel is the
best trigger to have in your pistol.
The main purpose of a
defensive pistol is to
shoot those things that endanger you and others!
I am frequently asked by Glock shooters what is the
proper/best trigger pull weight for their Glocks. What is the difference between
a trigger for target and one for self defense? This subject is hotly debated, argued and is rife with contradictions. The first thing I must make clear is that my
position is based on an assumption that you are a safe law abiding shooter. That is,
you
will keep your finger off the trigger until you are absolutely positive that you
must immediately fire! Practice and preach this or suffer the consequences. You will not point your firearm at anything unless you
are: one, legally justified to do so; and two, you are willing to damage it severely or destroy it.
Finger off the trigger until you must
immediately fire!
The status quo: "Lighter is better for target and heavier is better for self
defense." Let's examine these. Lighter is better for target shooting because you
are seeking the most efficient trigger pull to enhance your ability to shoot
precisely. Consider "lighter"
to be read as 3.5-5.5 lbs.. Lighter triggers make it easier to
place your shot. This is
simple physics. You are attempting to steady an object that weighs a little less than two
pounds while you are simultaneously exerting up to 12 lbs. of force against
the trigger. Once the sights are aligned, a lighter trigger pull will
cause the pistol to move less before the bullet exits the barrel.
The lighter the trigger pull the less
the pistol moves when the trigger is pulled!
The lighter the
trigger pull weight the less the muzzle will move as you pull the trigger through to fire
the pistol. The pistol will move less because of the weight you exert on the trigger
is less, regardless of how fast you pull the trigger. So why is light good for target but bad for self defense? Are
we not seeking efficiency? Why is efficiency in punching paper more important
than wining a gunfight or our survival? Pistols are defensive weapons when used
by law abiding persons. You are reacting to the actions of another or others which you
believe rises to the level of justifying you to use force, deadly or
otherwise. One-the actions of these individuals justify the use of your pistol to defend
yourself! Two-you are playing catch up
because you are reacting defensively (vs.-offensively)-and you want a heavy
inefficient trigger pull because you are afraid of being sued? You are willing
to cede your life because of civil liability!
The trigger is the heart of any
pistol. Get a good one!
I say "heavy inefficient
trigger pull", why? What is my definition of heavy? Anything above 7
lbs. What is inefficient? A trigger with excessive movement to fire the pistol
for the first shot and excessive movement to reset the trigger for subsequent
shots. We are told the concept of hitting things with bullets is to place
your primary focus on the front sight of the pistol and not trigger manipulation.
Once you have decided something needs to be shot to save your life or another
persons life you have to place a bullet or bullets into another living thing. You must
put your front sight on the object where
you intend to deliver your ballistic energy. Now if you have a heavy trigger
pull weight in your pistol you
realize how much concentration it takes to shoot well with this heavy
trigger. But wait a minute the experts tell us that under the stresses of a
gunfight concentration will be difficult for most and impossible for some. Now
knowing your trigger pull is
heavy and concentration on your sights is going to be difficult you will focus on pulling the trigger.
How will you pull the trigger? Very rapidly because your
already playing catch up and you know from your training that the trigger offers allot of
resistance and it is difficult under the best of circumstances to shoot well.
You will
not focus on the front sight because your mind is screaming shoot now launch
some lead! The
heavier the trigger pull the more pressure will be applied to the trigger and
subsequently to the pistol and this pressure will cause the muzzle to move off the line of sight
when you exert this much pressure to pull the trigger. How is this possible? It
that physics thing again. Your pistol weighs almost
two pounds you are trying to steady it while rapidly maybe even violently
applying up to six times its weight (depending on the trigger pull weight) to pull the trigger, this will
likely cause the muzzle to move and the bullet(s) to strike off the intended target. I
said the primary focus should be on the front sight. But it is difficult to do
this when we realize how critical trigger manipulation is. The fact of the
matter is of the two fundamentals sight alignment and trigger
pull-trigger pull is more critical to insuring hitting what you aim or
point at! If you miss-align your sights even out to seven yards you still
hit within six inches of where the pistol was aimed. If you jerk the trigger the
shot will go low by a few feet and possibly miss all together. Feet or inches I
would choose inches. Using or issuing a pistol with a heavy trigger pull is a
perceived low cost solution to training and avoiding liability. Because "how
could they pull the trigger negligently with a heavy trigger pull?"
but the inverse is true. The heavier trigger pulls leads to the shooter "prepping
the trigger"-that is placing your finger on the trigger in
preparation to firing your shot and moving the trigger to the rear to take out
the slack or the excess front end movement of the trigger right before it
releases the firing pin. Prepping the trigger or placing your finger in the
trigger housing prior to actually firing the pistol is negligent! Remember-you
will keep your finger off the trigger until you are absolutely positive that you
must immediately fire! Practice and preach this or suffer the consequences! The
mindset that some people express to me and much too often for my comfort is that "I
like a heavy trigger because I can put my finger on the trigger and prep it by feel
so
that when covering a suspect/subject/intruder etc. if they move I can react and shoot
them before they shoot me!"
The heavier the trigger the more
likely the shooter will prep the trigger for a perceived advantage!
Think about this. The experts say that your body will go through several
changes when involved in a critical incident and or a gunfight. Some of changes they
state will occur are that you will lose the ability to perform a fine motor
skill (i.e. precise trigger manipulation), tactile sensation (the ability to feel with your finger tips) and your
body will operate with gross motor movement. According to the
experts, you will not
be capable of; pulling the trigger precisely you will pull the trigger and fire the
pistol when you place your finger on the trigger!
Wait-if you can't feel the trigger or its pull
weight and your going to pull hard what difference does trigger pull weight
make?
So why do you need a heavier trigger pull when you will
not be capable of feeling or sensing this heavier trigger weight?
What I have been told by various firearms instructors is they think "Heavier"
is safer, politically correct and because the cost of teaching people to shoot
effectively is cost prohibitive. But we know that the argument of heavier
equals safer is not true, because people will place their trigger
finger on the trigger to prep the triggers to gain a perceived
edge. We know that once you place your finger on the trigger under stress you
will very likely fire your pistol regardless of trigger weight!
So then why does the trigger pull weight make a
difference? Here's why. Because under stress the trigger pull weight becomes either an
asset or a liability. The heavier the trigger pull weight the
more the pistol will move-liability!
The more movement the more you will miss! The lighter the trigger
pull weight the less the pistol will move and the greater the odds your
bullet will go where you want it-asset!! This means that a lighter
trigger means more hits!
Under stress you will not feel the
trigger or its weight!
What do the numbers say about trigger pull weights and hit ratios in actual gunfights?
-New York City Police Department (N.Y.P.D.) Glocks with 12 lb. triggers
15% hit
ratio*.
-Los Angeles County Sheriff Department (L.A.C.S.D.) Double/Single Action
trigger, first shot double action approx. 12 lb. double action subsequent single action shots approx
5 lb. trigger pull weight 51% hit
ratio*
* SPECIAL REPORT: FIREARMS, Aveni, Thomas; Law and Order, Vol.
51, No.8 August 2003
Just to give you some insight into the importance of a good trigger and good
trigger manipulation (a good trigger being a smooth light consistent pull with
little or no trigger over-travel-my definition)
The FBI's Firearms Training
Unit wrote a manual entitled; Advanced Firearms Instructional Techniques,
January 1999, they dedicate seven (7) pages to sight alignment issues and
thirteen (13) to trigger control. Why are more pages dedicated to trigger pull
than to sight alignment? Reason, if you can't control and manipulate the trigger
effectively you will not hit things that are trying to hurt you. The FBI
issues their Glock pistols with 5.5 lb. trigger connectors! They determined that
anything heavier resulted in poor performance by their agents during
stressful shooting conditions!
If heavier is safer or
better, then why don't all firearms have heavier triggers?
The single action (read this as lightweight
triggers) 12 gauge pump action shotguns, 5.56mm
AR-15 series of rifles and various submachine guns have trigger pull
weights ranging from 2.5 lbs to 6 lbs. Why do these weapons which deliver a
greater ballistic payload not merit 25 lb. triggers if the real concern is
avoiding civil liability? I believe this is a contradiction!
Let's see, you use a double action pistol with a
12 lb. trigger pull but you have a shotgun, assault rifle or
submachine gun with a 3 lb. trigger. More power, lighter trigger!
"Yes, but when you need a shotgun,
assault rifle or submachine gun it's really bad." So
using this logic, if someone is only trying to kill you with a
pistol, knife or bat that's not so bad and you should use the under powered
pistol with a heavy and inefficient trigger pull that is difficult to shoot
well? Not if you want to live!
Proper TRAINING
insures firearms safety not increasing the trigger pull weight!
Again, if your intention is to hit where you
are aiming your Glock, and if accuracy and speed are an issue, a smooth lighter
Ghost trigger in the 3.5 to 5.5 lb. range with little or no trigger over-travel is the
best trigger to have in your pistol. I addressed the lighter is
better point now I'll define trigger over-travel. What is trigger over-travel? It is the excessive
rearward movement of the trigger after the firing pin has been released by the
sear to fire the pistol. Why is limiting or stopping over-travel
important? Very simply to stop pistol movement while the bullet is in the
barrel. You need to do this to insure the pistol stays aligned with the target
and the bullet goes where it was aimed. Eliminating trigger over-travel is so
critical to precise shot placement that all target rifles /
pistols, sniper rifles and expensive self defense pistols have trigger
over-travel systems incorporated in their designs. If the worlds best shooters
demand these systems to insure their success and survival so should you.
The Glock semi-automatic pistol
as designed has excessive movement and trigger over-travel. I believe this was done to
simplify the manufacturing of the pistol and from a manufacturers stand point it
was brilliant. Mr. Glock makes a pistol where all parts will interchange between
like models without the required fitting that is common to all other handgun
designs. But because these same tolerances make the Glock so easy to manufacture
it
results in a very sloppy trigger pull. We already know that the trigger is the
heart of any pistol This where the Ghost triggers come in. Our patented Rocket
& Tactical triggers eliminate trigger over-travel our Ultimate, Ranger and
Patrol increases the reliability of the triggers and pistol. How the Rocket
& Tactical use the patented Trigger Control Tabs which are fitted to the
pistol eliminating trigger over-travel. These trigger connectors stop trigger
movement at the instant of firing resulting in precise bullet placement. The
Ultimate, Ranger & Patrol utilize the patent pending Debris Channel. This
debris channel is a hole manufactured into the trigger connector that removes
debris or any foreign matter from the trigger system making the Glock trigger
mechanism more reliable.
Keep your finger off the trigger until you are absolutely positive that you
must immediately fire! Practice and preach this or suffer the consequences!
Arthur Viani